07/19/2016 AT 08:20 PM EDT
The couple tied the knot on July 2 at the Basilica of the Sacred Heart on the campus of the University of Notre Dame in Indiana, and became the first celebrity bride and groom to get married at the historic church.
The Feed the Beast star looked beautiful in her white off the shoulder wedding gown custom made by designer and bridesmaid Rochelle Rodriguez. For the reception, Cummings, 39, wore a second dress also created by Rodriguez. Meanwhile, the Limitless actor was dapper in a black tuxedo and color coordinated bowtie.
A total of nine bridesmaids and nine groomsmen were in the couple’s wedding party including Cummings’ former Astronaut Wives Club costar JoAnna Garcia Swisher, Cummings’ manager and bridesman Todd Diener as well as the bride’s mother Cheryl, who served as matron of honor. Groomsmen included People v O.J. Simpson star Billy Magnussen and UnREAL actor Josh Kelly.
Cummings shared a sweet wedding photo of the new Mr. and Mrs. Degnan on social media. “Words cannot describe the joy, light, laughter and love that @tomdegnan and I experienced this weekend,” she captioned her picture. “I will always cherish the moment I entered the church and saw the smiling faces of everyone we know and love, before looking down the aisle and seeing the man I always dreamed about before I even knew him. This was all worth the wait and now I understand when people said to never, ever settle. For the 150+ people who were still holding strong at the end of the night and were able to be part of that unbelievable Piano Man finale, I cannot even think of that moment without getting choked up.”
Adding, “It was truly an unexpected and emotional moment that will fill my heart and spirit for years to come.”
The newlyweds celebrated their honeymoon in Rome, Italy and capped off their romantic getaway with a trip to New York City to watch the Broadway sensation Hamilton.